Delicious Giant Pizza Bagels

This whole giant pizza bagel thing actually started when I totally blanked on grabbing pizza dough after swearing we'd do homemade pizza on a Friday. I was halfway to meltdown mode, but then I remembered we had some leftover breakfast bagels, and suddenly, genius struck. Once you try these, you'll crave the buttery garlic crunch and that gooey cheese every week—they’re off-the-charts tasty. Something about the garlic butter melting into the toasty bagel and mixing with the sauce and bubbling cheese just hits different. They're the perfect mix of crispy outsides, soft middles, and stretchy cheese. Seriously, why pay for fancy pizza when you can make these in your kitchen?

Had my son's buddy Jake over when I tossed these together, and next day his mom texts me laughing because he begged for my "magical pizza thing." I cracked up telling her they're dead simple, but now her family’s hooked too. Turns out bagel-sized pizzas are fun for kids but also perfect when grownups want something chill. I've put them out with salad and wine for friends and everyone goes wild—not a clue they're eating what’s basically tricked-out kid food.

Dreamy Ingredients

• Store-bought plain bagels have just the right chew and sturdiness—they hold up better than the fancy bakery ones here
• Garlic-herb butter takes these bagels from decent to ridiculously good—I've tried skipping this, and nope, don’t do it
• Thick pizza sauce wins—thin and runny just soaks the bagels, so I sometimes strain extra liquid off if needed
• Freshly grated mozzarella melts way better than the bagged shreds—skip the anti-caking stuff and you’ll get epic cheese pull
• Tiny pepperoni gives you more crispy, poppable edges—way better topping coverage than the huge ones
• Scatter of parmesan at the end makes them taste super legit, with that punchy cheesy kick

Save

Easy Instructions

The real wow factor comes from the garlic butter blend.

I used plain butter the first time, and it was good, but adding garlic and herbs turned the whole thing up a notch. I just mash it all with a fork until everything's mixed for even flavor.

Accidentally pre-toasting the bagels was a happy discovery.

After leaving the buttered bagels in the oven for a quick few minutes before topping, I realized pre-toasting keeps them from going soggy. Now I always give them a 3-minute oven trip while prepping everything else.

Keep the sauce layer pretty light.

Piling on sauce made mine soggy disasters at first. Now, just a couple spoonfuls per bagel half, smoothed right to the edge, is spot on for that awesome crisp edge.

Let that cheese go wild over the sides.

The best bits are the parts where cheese melts down and turns crispy. I always spread it all the way to—and a bit past—the edges. My kid now begs for "crispy cheese bits."

Don’t forget: pull them out sooner than you think!

Once the cheese melts with some golden spots, they're ready. Learned the hard way that waiting for 'pizzeria coloring' just dries out the bagels. About 10 minutes is just right in my oven.

I started basic with just cheese or pepperoni but have gotten creative over time. Sautéing toppings like mushrooms and peppers first is key—they let off too much water if you don’t. I’ve even experimented with wild bagel flavors; everything bagels are my go-to, and cinnamon raisin gives this weird but awesome sweet-and-savory breakfast twist my kids always want in the morning.

Awesome Pairings

I've served these with a super simple salad (just olive oil and lemon is plenty) for an easy dinner that feels less like snacking on carbs. When we do movie night, I chop up raw veggies, throw out some ranch, and let everyone snack away. Cold weather? They’re great with tomato soup. Weekend brunch? Make mini versions and serve up with scrambled eggs—total crowd-pleaser.

Fun Spin-Offs

Go buffalo style with shredded rotisserie chicken tossed in hot sauce instead of pepperoni and go half mozzarella, half blue cheese. My veggie-loving sister loves mushrooms, black olives, and peppers as toppings. Or, try a Mediterranean one—swap out pizza sauce for pesto, then add feta, spinach, and some cherry tomatoes. For special mornings, do breakfast ones with eggs, bacon, and cheddar—it’s now our Christmas morning tradition.

New Twists

Honestly, you’ll get the best texture if you eat these right out of the oven. But if you’re planning ahead, assemble everything and hold off on baking until just before mealtime. Sometimes I get them all ready in the morning, wrap up, and put in the fridge—just pop them in the oven with a couple more minutes. To reheat leftovers, wrap in foil and bake at 300°F for five minutes (they’re not quite as magical, but still solid). Stick to the oven because the microwave gets them chewy instead of crisp.

Save

I've made these for quick meals, after-school treats, even cut them up for party snacks. Something about their mix of crunchy, chewy, and melty just never gets old. Now my kids’ friends ask for these every time, and I’ve caught my husband fixing one as a midnight snack more than once. Who knew a last-minute meal could get bumped up to top family favorite so fast? Sometimes pantry disasters turn into the best comfort food ever.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can I swap the type of bagel?

Sure! Everything bagels add extra depth, and whole wheat is a healthier swap. Just skip sweet ones like cinnamon raisin.

→ How do I keep leftover pizza bagels fresh?

Let leftovers cool, then store them in a sealed container in the fridge for up to 3 days. Warm them in a 350°F oven for 5-7 minutes.

→ Are these freezer-friendly?

Totally! Freeze on a tray first, then transfer to a freezer-safe bag. Cook straight from frozen at 350°F for 15-20 minutes.

→ What veggie toppings can I use?

Try bell peppers, mushrooms, olives, onions, spinach, or even pineapple. Plant-based pepperoni is also a great alternative.

→ Can these be made in an air fryer?

Absolutely! Cook them at 350°F for 5-6 minutes. The cheese melts perfectly, and you won't heat up your whole kitchen.