Irresistible Feta Delight

This feta and cream cheese creation happened on a whim one afternoon as I was prepping for a Mediterranean-inspired get-together. Torn between putting out a cheese platter or something sweet, I thought—why not do both in one dish? Mixing that zippy feta with silky cream cheese, then adding fresh herbs and a pop of lemon, totally nails that line between savory and sweet. Now, friends and family always want this for brunches and it's the hands-down favorite starter at my house!

Even Diane, my neighbor who usually skips cheesecake for being "too sweet," asked how to make it after tasting this at our block cookout! And my father-in-law—famous for turning up his nose at anything "fancy"—went back for thirds last time. That blend of sweet with tangy and savory really wins over pretty much everyone, even the skeptics.

Tasty Ingredients

• Feta cheese: The solid block (skip the pre-crumbled) is best for flavor and moisture. Greek brings the bold flavor, but French is nice if you're into something gentler.
• Cream cheese: That’s what makes it rich and smooth and keeps the feta in check. I always grab full-fat Philly, let it warm up on the counter. Lighter ones just make things gritty and sad.
• Fresh thyme: Adds an herbal layer that just clicks with feta and cream cheese. Some summers I'll toss in a little oregano too for fun.
• Honey: A bit in the mix balances out the salty cheese, and I like to drizzle some stronger stuff for a fancy look at the end. Warm honey over slices looks cool and tastes even better.
• Lemon zest: Even just a little wakes up all the flavors. Skip it and you'll notice right away it's missing something special.

Save

Detailed Instructions

Serving strategy

Let the cake stand out by getting it just barely cool before you serve—take it out 30 minutes ahead so flavors shine. For presentation, drizzle honey over the top and pile up thyme sprigs and lemon zest in the middle. When it's appetizer time, put out crackers or toasted bread. If you want a sweet vibe, go with fresh fruits or figs on the side.

Cooling discipline

Resist the urge to dig in too early—set it out until it's cool, then stick it in the fridge for at least 4 hours, overnight is even better. Whenever I've tried to rush, it just didn't slice right. Good things really do come to those who wait.

Gentle baking

Don't rush the oven—slow, low baking gives the best texture. A water bath can help avoid cracks and keeps it super creamy. Just wrap your springform in foil, set it in another pan and pour in hot water. It's ready when the edges are firm but the middle jiggles. Overdo it and you'll get dryness, underdo it and it won’t hold together when you slice.

Flavor balancing

Play with honey until you get just enough sweetness to balance the feta—not too much or you'll confuse your taste buds, too little and it's sharp. Thyme and lemon zest add layers of freshness, so taste before adding eggs and tweak as you go.

Cheese preparation

Cheeses need to be soft and at room temp for that dreamy texture. I beat cream cheese until creamy, then slowly fold in feta. Feta won’t ever go totally smooth—if you want a silkier vibe, pulse it in the food processor first. A few lumps mean fun hits of saltiness as you eat.

Crust perfection

I start with crumbs and mix in melted butter until it’s damp and sticks together, maybe a spoon of chopped thyme if I’m feeling fancy. Press it into the pan with something flat (measuring cup, glass, whatever). Don’t smash it too firm—the graham sweetness really balances the rest.

The first time I made this, I used way too much feta—the saltiness was wild! Tweaking the feta-to-cream cheese combo led to the perfect mix where you still get that feta punch but it's not overwhelming. Tried rosemary once (too strong) and basil (not great with the cheeses), but thyme and lemon ended up being just right.

Best Matches

This dish goes everywhere. For brunch, I serve thin slices with fresh fruit. At dinner, it kicks things off with a simple arugula salad and a lemony olive oil drizzle. Works at wine parties with Sauvignon Blanc or Pinot Noir. Around the holidays, a sprinkle of cranberries and pistachios feels extra special. It always travels well for potlucks and I make it ahead whenever possible.

Fun Variations

Mix things up with whatever ingredients you like. Mediterranean spin? Add olives and sun-dried tomatoes. Summertime? Fresh corn and basil make it pop. My Greek friend uses dried oregano and tops it with roasted red peppers. For parties, mini cheesecakes baked in muffin tins are cute and super easy to share.

Storage Hacks

This will stay tasty in the fridge for about five days, though the crust gets a little softer the longer it sits. Keep it in the springform with the side ring on and wrap tight. Wait to drizzle honey and add herbs until just before serving. Any leftover pieces wrap up great for breakfast—don’t knock it till you try it with coffee!

Save

This started as a spur-of-the-moment idea for a dinner with friends, and now it's kind of my calling card. The surprise of classic cheesecake texture with that unexpected feta zing always makes people smile at the first bite. It’s a favorite when you’re after something interesting that people will keep talking about. Even folks who play it safe with food usually end up loving it!

Recipe FAQs

→ Is it okay to make this in advance?

Definitely! Letting it chill for 1-2 days actually makes it tastier. Just hold off on the honey drizzle and herbs until you're ready to serve.

→ Which type of feta works best?

Sheep's milk feta from Greece really shines here, but any kind will do. For a softer flavor, rinse the feta really well and pat it dry before using.

→ Can I swap out the graham cracker crust?

Yep! Crushed herb crackers, buttery bread crumbs, or even a flaky phyllo base can switch things up for a Mediterranean spin.

→ What pairs well with this dish?

You can serve it with crostini, fresh fruit, roasted veggies, or as part of a mezze spread. A light rosé or crisp white wine works wonderfully too!

→ Do I serve it cold or at room temp?

Traditionally, it's served chilled like you would any cheesecake. But leaving it out to reach room temperature makes the flavors even bolder.