Irresistible Buffalo Chicken Bake

I came up with this buffalo chicken bake totally by chance after wing night left me with a bunch of spicy chicken and a lonely ball of pizza dough no one remembered. Instead of letting either go to waste, I mashed them together, popped it in the oven, and hoped for the best. The result was this crispy-on-the-outside, fluffy-in-the-middle roll packed with fiery chicken, oozing cheese, and that super tasty buffalo-ranch mix. My crew went nuts for it—we had a tug-of-war over the last piece. It's now our comfort food fix when we crave those wing flavors, but don't feel like sticky fingers or tons of cleanup. The crunch of the dough against the gooey cheese and soft chicken is honestly the best part.

One time when a snowstorm dumped over us, my friend Lisa stopped by with restless kids, and we were all stuck indoors. I used whatever was in the fridge to whip this up. Lisa laughed and took a million photos to send to her husband because she said it looked so amazing. Even her sauce-hating kids finished every bite and begged her to learn how to make it. Now Lisa makes this regularly and says it's been a total lifesaver on terrible weather days when venturing out is just not happening.

Essential Gear

• Rotisserie or leftover chicken: Grab a store-bought rotisserie bird or use whatever chicken is hanging around. I always go for shredding—just pull it apart with your hands for a nice texture.
• Store-bought pizza dough: Ready-made dough is perfect. Defrost it in advance if frozen. I always keep a dough ball in my freezer for last-minute dinner adventures.
• Cheddar & mozzarella: Both are key—cheddar for sharpness and mozzarella for epic meltiness. You really want both for the best bite.
• Buffalo sauce (the real stuff): Don't use regular hot sauce here. Buffalo sauce is its own thing and you'll notice the difference in this dish.
• Ranch dressing: It cools down the heat and brings that irresistible creamy vibe. Even if you don't love ranch, trust me, don't leave it out!

Save

Easy Prep Guide

Let the dough chill out

Spread some flour on your counter. Roll that dough out into a rough rectangle, about 12x15 inches. If it keeps bouncing back, just leave it for five minutes and then try again—it needs to relax a little. Don’t sweat it if it looks messy.

Mix your saucy spread

In a tiny bowl, blend up your ranch with the rest of the buffalo sauce. It turns into a creamy, tangy orange dip—super tasty smeared on the dough (and you’ll want extra later for dipping too).

Chicken prep

Rip or chop your chicken into little bits, toss with a quarter cup buffalo sauce, and make sure it’s all coated. Taste and add more sauce if you like it extra hot—start small, though! Let this sit while you work on everything else so that flavor really sinks in.

Time to layer

Spread that buffalo-ranch sauce all over, but leave about an inch bare around the edge—you don’t want spills! Sprinkle your saucy chicken all over, then cover everything with plenty of cheddar and mozzarella. Pile on the cheese—it holds things together and makes every bite gooey.

Roll and seal

Pick one long side and carefully start rolling into a big log, like a burrito. Move slow so the filling stays put. Once you’re done, pinch the ends and seam closed so you don’t risk a cheesy explosion in your oven.

Get it crispy

Flip your roll seam-side down onto a greased tray or some parchment. For an extra golden look, brush the top with olive oil (totally optional). Bake for thirty minutes at 425°F until the outside is crisp and it sounds hollow if you tap it.

Wait before you slice

This is the toughest part. Let it hang out for five minutes before cutting. If you don’t wait, all that filling might flood out. Slice gently with a serrated knife using a gentle back-and-forth motion for slices that stay together.

Throwing together this buffalo chicken bake is now my favorite chicken leftovers trick. It turns bland meat into something super craveable and impressive. My first attempt, I worried the dough would blow out with all that filling, but pizza dough is pretty forgiving if you treat it gently.

I can’t stress enough: mix cheddar and mozzarella. Mozzarella brings the melt; cheddar punches things up with flavor. I tried using only mozzarella one time and it was fine… but nowhere near as tasty as the two-cheese combo.

This whole thing is easy to riff on. Maybe add chopped celery for crunch or toss in some cream cheese to make things really rich. Football season? Make a double batch—there’s never a crumb left when I do!

Layering buffalo sauce with ranch is key. Too much straight buffalo is overwhelming when baked inside bread, but mixing it with ranch dials it back to creamy-spicy, so pretty much everyone loves it. Even my mother-in-law—who thinks spicy food is scary—asks for seconds of this.

Rolling the dough takes a little practice, but don’t let an uneven log stress you out. Even a roll that leaks or looks a bit rustic still tastes awesome. Nobody cares if it’s wonky, it’ll disappear just as fast!

How to Serve

Cut your buffalo chicken bake into thick slices so all those gooey, cheesy layers show. I set out bowls of ranch and extra buffalo sauce for folks who like to double-dip, plus some celery sticks to stick with that buffalo theme. Works as a hearty main with salad, or, pulled apart smaller, an awesome party snack. On game days, I bake this with wings so everyone gets what they want… without making a mess during the game!

Ways to Switch Things Up

This is super versatile. Add chopped celery and blue cheese crumbles for a classic spin, or toss in bacon if you want to go all out. Cream cheese in the filling makes it extra creamy, and some jalapeño slices punch up the heat for spicy food fans. Swap in barbecue sauce for the buffalo to make a BBQ chicken twist, or mix up the cheeses with whatever’s in the fridge.

Storing for Later

Leftovers last up to three days in the fridge, though nothing beats it fresh from the oven. For reheating, wrap slices in foil and bake at 350°F for ten minutes—this way the crust stays crisp. Skip the microwave unless you don’t mind it going soft. You can assemble the whole thing and freeze before baking—just thaw overnight and bake with a little extra time. Already baked and frozen? It will still taste good but the dough might firm up a little.

Save

This buffalo chicken bake keeps getting requested again and again at my place because it delivers everything people love about wings in a way that actually fits a normal dinner plan. It’s filling enough to count as a main dish, mellow enough for crazy weekdays, and fancy-looking without being real work. Even better, you can make it with basic stuff already in the kitchen—no special runs to the store, just honest comfort food that brings everyone together.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can raw chicken be used in this recipe?

Using pre-cooked chicken is a better choice since it only bakes 30 minutes. Cook and shred chicken breasts ahead or grab a rotisserie bird to save time.

→ How do I keep the filling from escaping?

Pinch the dough edges firmly to seal them, and place the roll seam-side down on your tray, so it stays shut while baking.

→ What if I want less spice?

No problem! Add less buffalo sauce, swap it for a mild hot sauce, or increase the ranch to tone it down.

→ How can I cut it neatly without breaking it apart?

Once baked, let it cool for 5-10 minutes so the filling sets. Then, take a serrated knife and gently saw through for cleaner slices.

→ Can this be frozen to prep ahead?

Yes! Freeze it raw for up to three months. Thaw it overnight in the fridge and bake, adding another 5-10 minutes to the cooking time.