Save
It’s kind of wild—everyone swears they know the best way to do egg salad, but then you taste one and it blows you away. After messing around for ages, I realized it’s not just what you toss in but how you handle those eggs. Like most things worth doing, patience and care totally pay off.
Last week? My super fussy nephew wanted more. That’s when I figured I had all the details nailed.
Tasty Essential Ingredients
- Your Go-To Bread: I love toasted sourdough, but use whatever you like
- Plenty of Salt and Pepper: Don’t be shy here
- The Mustard Fix: Just a smidge wakes everything up
- Top-Notch Mayo: Skip the low-fat stuff for now
- Super Fresh Eggs: Fresher eggs taste awesome but can be tricky to peel
Save
Let’s Make This Happen
- The Mix:
- Start slow with your mayo, tossing it in a bit at a time. Mix just until it looks right, then hit it with a dab of mustard, salt, and pepper. Taste and keep tweaking—you do you.
- The Mash:
- Fork-mash those eggs, leaving them chunky so you still get a little bite. Also, if your day’s been rough, this step is weirdly calming.
- The Cool Down:
- Toss those eggs into an ice bath when they’re done. My grandma swore this trick makes peeling a breeze—and she never missed.
- The Egg Start:
- Put your eggs in cold water, then boil them. Once bubbling, cover and turn off the heat. Let them chill out for 10 minutes. Seriously—this never lets me down.
The first time I tried, I hurried through and ended up with yolks that had that awkward green outline. Live and learn—good food needs a little time.
Effortless Assembly
Start with a stack of lettuce on your bread to fend off sogginess. Pile the egg salad on top. Go big.
Fun Serving Ideas
Pop a bunch of chips on your plate for extra crunch. Or, if you’re feeling like it, throw together some greens and splash a bit of olive oil on top.
Personalize Yours
Chopped pickles take it up a notch, or toss in fresh herbs. Sometimes I go wild and add smashed avocado or sprinkle a little paprika for a kick.
Easy Storage
Egg salad lasts about three days in the fridge, sealed up tight. But honestly, it’s usually gone long before then around here.
Save
All those lunches and picnic days? This is the one thing I always reach for when I need comfort. The simple stuff ends up being the food you crave most.
Recipe FAQs
- → How should I store leftover egg salad?
- Keep egg salad sealed in the fridge, and it'll stay good for about 3 days.
- → Can egg salad be prepared ahead of time?
- Sure thing! Mix it up in advance and keep it in the fridge. Build your sandwich when you're set to eat.
- → What's the easiest way to make hard-boiled eggs?
- Start with cold water, bring it to a boil with the eggs, then turn off the heat and let them sit covered for 10 minutes.
- → Is there something else I can swap for mayonnaise?
- Greek yogurt or smashed avocado are great substitutes for mayo and make it healthier.
- → What type of bread works best for this?
- Whatever you like works - sourdough, white bread, or wheat all do the trick. Toasting gives a nice crunch and keeps it from getting soggy.