Delicious Pistachio Ice Cream Treats

Three summers back, these pistachio cookie ice cream sandwiches happened by accident thanks to a boiling hot July evening. I wanted regular pistachio cookies but couldn't handle baking till the sun went down. Once the cookies cooled, I shoved some ice cream between them because I needed to cool off. Turns out, they're now my go-to summer treat. That rich nutty cookie with chilly vanilla ice cream is honestly all you need when it's blazing outside.

Why You'll Want These

• Even frozen, the cookies stay tender so you won't chip a tooth biting in
• Pistachios give off a deep, nutty flavor way beyond the usual sugar cookie
• Fix a batch of cookies ahead, stash in the freezer, pull 'em out to build when you want
• Easy enough for a lazy day but fancy enough for your friends to be impressed

Brought these to a summer BBQ, and my friend’s little one who swears he “doesn’t do nuts in sweets” inhaled three before anyone spilled that there were pistachios inside. His mom was in stitches at his face when he found out. Now every get-together, he asks for “those green ice cream things.”

Must-Have Ingredients

• Unsalted butter - I go for unsalted so I can add just the right amount of salt. It needs to be soft, though, or your dough will be lumpy. I’ve lost track of how many times I’ve nuked cold butter for a few seconds just to get it soft enough.
• Ground pistachios - This is what makes these special. I get shelled, unsalted pistachios and blitz them in my food processor till they’re fine but not mushy. Pre-ground stuff just isn’t as tasty or fresh.
• Vanilla ice cream - Just plain, good quality vanilla lets the pistachio stand out. I tried fancy flavors before, but French vanilla is my favorite because it’s richer.
• Chopped pistachios - I chop these bigger than the ground ones in the dough for some crunch around the edges. Plus, it makes them look fancy with zero effort.

Save

Simple How-To Guide

• Getting your butter right - Aim for butter that squishes a bit but doesn’t look greasy. Too hard makes your dough bumpy, too soft and your cookies turn into pancakes.
• Fridge time matters - I know, waiting stinks, but chill the dough for an hour so it holds together and the flavors build. If you’re eager, you’ll wind up with cookies that bake into a single blob. Sometimes I just leave the dough overnight in the fridge.
• Even cookies = happier sandwiches - I scoop with a measuring spoon or cookie scoop, aiming for about one tablespoon per ball. Mismatched sizes means lopsided sandwiches—been there!
• Bake just enough - Watch ‘em bake: pull out when the edges look barely golden and the centers are still soft. As they cool, they firm up, staying perfect for stuffing with ice cream.
• Cool it - Leave them on the baking tray for five minutes before you try to move them. If you rush, they’ll fall apart right in your hands. (Please don’t ask how I know!)

Don't Miss These Tips

• Whip up the dough anytime and park it in the fridge for three days max
• Let the ice cream sit out just until it's soft enough to spread but not goopy
• Build your sandwiches fast or you’ll wind up with melty puddles everywhere

The first time I tried these, I made the rookie mistake of grabbing cookies that were still a bit warm—ice cream melted instantly and ran all over me. Now, I always let those cookies cool completely and keep my ice cream as frozen as possible but soft enough to spread. I only do a couple at a time and stash finished ones back in the freezer before making more.

Fun Ways to Enjoy

Serve these up at backyard hangouts when you want something cool without slaving in the kitchen. I love wrapping them in parchment with a little twine for the wow factor. If I’m hosting, sometimes I serve one on a small plate with some berries for color. For the kids, I swap chopped pistachios for rainbow sprinkles or mini chocolate chips—it’s always a hit.

Yummy Variations

Switch up the ice cream—pistachio ice cream packs a double punch. A swipe of Nutella or jam under the ice cream is next level. For the holidays, a little almond extract in the cookie dough and peppermint ice cream turns these into a winter treat. My favorite? Toss mini chocolate chips into the dough for a chocolate-and-pistachio combo I can’t stop eating.

How to Keep Them Fresh

These stash in the freezer up to two weeks, no problem. I wrap them one by one in parchment and throw the lot into a big freezer-safe tub or bag. To get that just-right soft bite, let them sit on the counter five minutes first. I like making a big batch on Sunday so there’s a stash anytime a sweet craving hits—especially on those muggy summer nights.

Save

Best Sandwich Tricks

• Roll sandwiches in chopped pistachios right after you put 'em together so the edges look great
• Underbake the cookies just a touch for a perfect chewy, soft bite once frozen
• Want totally round cookies? Chill the dough balls for about 15 minutes right before baking

I’ve whipped up these pistachio cookie ice cream sandwiches for summers at the pool, kid parties, or on those “ice cream counts as dinner” nights. That mix of crumbly nutty cookies and cold smooth ice cream is just the ultimate summer treat. They’re super easy to tweak, really straightforward to make, and people always rave about them. Nothing beats that for a sweet pick-me-up.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can I swap in store-bought ice cream?

Of course! Just pick a high-quality vanilla version and let it soften a bit so it’s easier to handle while putting the sandwiches together.

→ Can I prep the cookies beforehand?

Definitely! You can bake the cookies up to three days early. Store them airtight at room temp, or freeze for up to a month, then thaw when ready to use.

→ What’s the easiest way to grind pistachios?

A food processor works like a charm—pulse the nuts until they’re finely chopped but not clumpy. A coffee grinder or careful knife work gets the job done too!

→ Is it alright to use salted pistachios?

Yep, just cut back on any extra salt in the cookie dough to balance things out. Sweet and salty together taste amazing here!

→ How long will the finished sandwiches stay good?

Wrap them in plastic and keep in a sealed container in your freezer. They’re best enjoyed within a week but last fine for up to two weeks if stored well.

→ What could I combine with pistachio if I want to switch things up?

You’ve got options—chocolate, strawberries, or even more pistachio (as ice cream) pair nicely. Add a splash of rose water or some cardamom to the dough for a fun twist!