Save
These red potatoes get a mind-blowing makeover with garlic, herbs and parmesan, turning into a knockout side that goes with everything. You'll get that mouthwatering savory crust outside while keeping the centers soft and tender. I stumbled on this approach when trying to jazz up ordinary potatoes years back, and now it's my favorite impressive-yet-easy side dish for any meal.
The first time I whipped these up for my family on Sunday, everyone was asking for my secrets before we'd even gotten to dessert. My veggie-hating nephew somehow managed three helpings and now begs for my "magic potatoes" whenever he stops by.
What You'll Need
- Red potatoes: cut into quarters so they'll crisp up nicely while staying creamy inside
- Olive oil: helps create that gorgeous golden crust during high-heat roasting
- Minced garlic: grab whole cloves for way better taste than the jarred stuff
- Dried oregano: brings an herby kick that works magic with the garlic
- Salt and pepper: simple seasonings that make everything else pop
- Parmesan cheese: grate it yourself for the smoothest melt and best flavor
- Fresh parsley for garnish: gives a pop of green and fresh taste contrast
How To Make Them
- Heat your oven:
- Get your oven nice and hot at 400°F. While it's warming up, grab your baking dish and give it a quick spray so nothing sticks.
- Mix everything up:
- Grab a big bowl and throw in your quartered potatoes, olive oil, fresh garlic, oregano, salt, and pepper. Toss it all around until every bit of potato gets coated. Don't rush this part—you want that seasoning everywhere.
- First cheese layer:
- Toss half your parmesan onto those seasoned potatoes and mix again gently. The cheese will start sticking to the oil on the potatoes, which sets you up for that amazing crust later.
- Get ready to bake:
- Dump everything into your dish, trying to spread the potatoes out somewhat evenly. Don't worry if they touch or overlap a bit, but don't pile them too high or they won't cook through.
- Cover and bake first:
- Wrap that dish tightly with foil. This step matters a lot because it lets the potatoes steam a bit, getting them tender inside before we work on making them crispy.
- Add more cheese:
- After about 20 minutes, pull off the foil carefully—watch the steam! The potatoes should be getting soft. Now sprinkle the rest of your parmesan all over the top.
- Crisp them up:
- Put the dish back in the oven without any cover for another 20 minutes. This lets moisture escape so you get that perfect crispy outside while the cheese turns all golden and crusty.
- Finish and dig in:
- Take them out when they're done, scatter fresh parsley on top, and serve them right away while they're hot and crunchy for the best experience.
Save
My absolute favorite moment with this dish happens when I pull back the foil halfway through cooking. The kitchen suddenly fills with this incredible garlic-oregano smell that brings everyone wandering in asking when we can eat. It always takes me back to my grandma's Sunday suppers, where that roasted potato aroma meant something special was coming.
Top Potato Choices
Red potatoes work great here, but don't feel limited. Yukon golds bring a buttery taste that plays really well with the parmesan. Fingerlings look fancy if you're trying to impress dinner guests. No matter which type you pick, go for firm ones without any green spots or sprouts, and try to grab potatoes roughly the same size so they cook evenly.
Prep Them Early
You can get a head start on these potatoes when you're busy. Clean and cut them up to a day before, then keep them in cold water in your fridge so they don't turn brown. You can also mix up your seasonings ahead and store them separately. When you're ready to cook, just drain the potatoes and dry them really well before moving forward with the recipe.
What To Eat With Them
These cheesy garlic potatoes taste amazing next to pretty much any protein. Try them with a simple roasted chicken for total comfort food vibes, or next to a grilled steak for something more fancy. They're great with fish too, especially salmon or cod. If you don't want meat, they're hearty enough to pair with a big salad and some roasted veggies for a filling meal that doesn't skimp on flavor.
Switch Up The Flavors
Think of this recipe as your starting point for tons of tasty versions. Swap the oregano for rosemary and thyme for a different herby taste. Want some heat? Throw in red pepper flakes or a little cayenne. A bit of smoked paprika adds incredible depth. And don't feel stuck with parmesan—try Pecorino Romano for a stronger kick, or add some mozzarella in the last baking round if you love those stretchy cheese pulls.
Save
Recipe FAQs
- → What kind of potatoes should I use?
Red potatoes are your best bet. They’re naturally firm and sweet, so they come out crispy on the outside but fluffy inside when roasted.
- → How can I get the potatoes to crisp up?
Coat them well with oil, use high heat, and roast them without covering. Parmesan adds extra crunch when added during roasting.
- → Can I swap minced garlic for fresh?
Absolutely! Using freshly minced garlic boosts both the flavor and aroma.
- → Can I prep this ahead of time?
You can mix the potatoes with the seasoning in advance. Then just pop them in the oven right before serving for that fresh, crispy texture.
- → What could I use instead of parsley?
Try chives, rosemary, or thyme. They’ll all add a nice herbaceous touch to your dish.
- → What dishes go well with these potatoes?
They pair wonderfully with grilled chicken, salmon, steak, or even as a side to a leafy salad for something lighter.