Creamy High-Protein Chocolate Treat

This whole chocolate pudding mashup with cottage cheese happened late one night when I was desperate for something sweet and realized I was out of anything dessert-related. Honestly, the idea of mixing cottage cheese and chocolate sounded questionable, but I was so committed to getting my chocolate fix, I just went for it.

My boyfriend always acts grossed out when I pull out the cottage cheese, but when he saw me digging into this, he genuinely wanted to know what fancy chocolate treat I had. At first he didn't buy it when I told him what was actually in there. He gave it a taste, then immediately went to blend up his own batch. No joke.

Dreamy Blender Lineup

• Honey: You just want a touch to sweeten things up
• Milk: Use whatever you've got – oat, almond, dairy, it's all good
• Cocoa powder: Go with the super dark kind if you want extra chocolate flavor
• Banana: Super ripe adds the best sweetness
• Peanut flour: That powdered peanut butter everyone knows about
• Cottage cheese: Full-fat is where the magic happens

Save

Mixing Everything Up

Topping Adventure

Here's where you just do whatever. Nip some peanut butter on top, or go all-out with banana slices, graham cracker bits, and some chocolate chips if you're feeling crazy. It's honestly just as fun to keep it simple.

Bowl Vibes

I won't judge if you eat this straight out of the blender, but tossing it in a cold bowl (stick one in the freezer for a few minutes) kicks it up a notch – makes it taste even fancier somehow. Plus, more room for toppings.

Texture Check

Take a spoonful – if it grips the spoon but still slides off when you tip it, it's ready. Too runny? Stir in a little more cocoa or peanut flour. If it's looking thick like cement, a splash of milk gets it silky again. I always just eyeball it.

Blender Blitz

Throw all the ingredients in your blender or food processor and start it on low. Once it starts moving, hit high and don't stop until not a single lump remains. You'll probably need to stop and push things down from the sides. Usually takes about a minute – you want it ultra-smooth, no cottage cheese chunks left behind.

My niece is going through a picky streak, so I made her a bowl last weekend without saying what was in it. She cleaned the whole thing out and asked for seconds. My sister texted me later wanting to know what went into it, apparently because that's the most protein the kid's had in forever!

Fun Twists

Sub in some chocolate protein powder for the cocoa if you want an even bigger protein kick. If you're feeling fruity, toss in frozen cherries for that Black Forest cake flavor. A splash of peppermint extract makes it taste like Thin Mints. Honestly, adding cold espresso turns it into a breakfast-friendly mocha treat I can't get enough of.

Times I Eat This

I've had it for dessert, breakfast, post-workout, or as a midday treat. It's one of those things that fits whatever time you need a little pick-me-up. Great protein boost after workouts. At night, it calms sugar cravings without messing with your sleep. In the morning, it's like supercharged fruit and yogurt – seriously delicious.

Leftover Game

Stick leftovers in the fridge and it'll last two or three days, though it does taste best right away. It gets a bit thicker after chilling, but just splash in some milk and stir to get it silky again. I pack mine tight in a jar to keep that weird pudding film from forming on top – trust me, it helps!

Save

I've lost count of the "healthy desserts" I've made that just taste like punishment, but this one actually hits the chocolate craving and doesn't make you feel weird after. It's now my favorite when I want something sweet but not heavy. My only regret? I wish I'd known about this trick sooner – I'd have skipped a lot of those sad, protein-free puddings. Next chocolate craving? Trust the cottage cheese. You won't regret it.

Recipe FAQs

→ What can I use instead of peanut flour?

Sure! You could swap it for PB2 or another powdered peanut butter product. Using protein powder also works, but the taste may shift.

→ What kind of banana works best?

Bananas with plenty of brown spots are ideal since they're much sweeter and will mix up super smooth.

→ How long will this last in the fridge?

Keep it sealed tight in a container and it should be good in the fridge for about 3 days. It might get thicker over time.

→ What toppings go well with this?

Fresh fruit like berries or sliced bananas, chopped nuts, granola, chocolate chips, or even some whipped cream are all great options.

→ Can I make it without dairy ingredients?

You could try using silken tofu or dairy-free yogurt instead of cottage cheese, but it'll change the protein and texture slightly.