Save
I found this chocolate frosted brownie recipe during a late-night Pinterest scrolling session when I should've been dealing with my taxes. You know how it goes – you search for something specific and suddenly it's midnight and your screen's full of chocolate? These brownies became my treat after finally submitting that tax extension.
My sister's husband normally talks about sweets as "okay" with all the excitement of reading a phone book, but he wolfed down three of these in one go and then asked to take extras home "for tomorrow." When someone who thinks vanilla ice cream is "pushing boundaries" wants seconds AND a doggy bag, you've clearly hit the jackpot.
Tasty Ingredients
- Dark and unsweetened chocolate: For deep, layered flavor
- Cocoa powder: Boosts the chocolate kick
- Butter: The foundation of all delicious things
- Honey: The unexpected trick that creates that almost-fudge texture
- Brown sugar: Adds those caramel notes that boost chocolate flavors
- Dual sugars in the frosting: Creates just the right consistency
Save
Brownie Creation Steps
- Smart Chocolate Melting
- These brownies shine because of how you treat the chocolate. Mix it gradually with butter in a double boiler or microwave it in brief bursts, mixing each time. Stop when it's mostly melted and let the warmth do the rest. This stops the chocolate from burning, which makes it clump up and ruins your brownie dreams. I check by rubbing some mixture with my fingers – if it feels grainy, keep stirring.
- Adding Honey Right
- Make sure you mix the honey in completely. I was doubtful about this ingredient too, but it gives these brownies that perfect almost-gooey-but-fully-cooked feel that makes people shut their eyes when they bite in. Don't try to swap it out, just go with this weird honey trick and you'll thank me after.
- Setting Up Your Pan
- Put parchment paper in your pan with extra hanging over two sides. This gives you handles to pull the whole batch out for easier frosting and cutting. Push the paper into the pan corners – everyone fights over corner brownies and nobody wants to lose chunks stuck to the pan. A quick spray of cooking oil on the paper gives extra protection.
- Waiting For Frosting
- The toughest part is letting the brownies cool fully before adding frosting. I've tried rushing and ended up with melted frosting everywhere. If you can't wait (I get it), pop the pan in your fridge for about 30 minutes to speed things up. The frosting works best at room temp – not too hard, not too runny. Just right, like in Goldilocks.
I brought these to my friend's new place last month. I put them on the sweets table next to a fancy bakery cake. By the night's end, my simple brownies were gone while half the pricey cake sat untouched. The host messaged me next day saying several people had asked for "the brownie recipe." One guest even said they were "worth breaking a diet for," probably the best compliment any dessert can get.
Delicious Twists
Add a bit of espresso powder to your batter – it makes the chocolate taste stronger without adding coffee flavor. Switch rainbow chips for smashed Oreos or chopped peanut butter cups for different tastes. For an adult version, mix some bourbon into your frosting. If you're feeling bold, sprinkle some flaky sea salt on top to create that sweet-salty combo that drives everyone wild.
Keeping Them Fresh
These brownies actually improve after sitting in the fridge overnight – the flavors blend together and they get even more fudgy. Keep them in a sealed container with parchment between each layer so they don't stick. They'll stay good for about 5 days in the fridge, though they've never lasted that long at my house. For keeping them longer, wrap unfrosted brownies tightly in plastic and foil, then freeze them.
Save
I've baked these frosted brownies so many times now, and they always wow everyone. There's something truly wonderful about making a dessert that causes people to forget their table manners and grab seconds while still chewing their first bite. Whether you go nostalgic with rainbow chips or keep it classic with just chocolate frosting, these brownies have that special something that makes folks ask, "Can I get your recipe?" And isn't that the best thing any baker can hear?
Recipe FAQs
- → Why do my brownies turn out too fluffy?
- Overmixing the eggs could be the culprit. Be careful and fold in the flour mixture gently, stopping as soon as everything is combined.
- → Can I substitute milk chocolate for dark chocolate?
- Sure, but the outcome will be sweeter and less bold. If you choose milk chocolate, try cutting back on the sugar a bit.
- → Is using two types of chocolate necessary?
- To get the best balance of flavors, yes. Combining dark and unsweetened chocolate ensures just the right mix of intense and smooth chocolatey notes.
- → Can I store these brownies in the freezer?
- Absolutely. Wrap each piece separately and store them for up to 3 months. Let them thaw at room temperature for about an hour before enjoying.
- → What does the honey add to this recipe?
- It keeps the brownies moist and prevents them from drying out too quickly. Choose a runny honey for the best result.