Irresistible Strawberry Cream Cheese Toast

This idea for strawberry cream cheese stuffed French toast popped up one lazy Sunday because I had stale brioche and some leftover strawberries plus cream cheese. Figured I’d throw them together before they went bad, and it ended up being everyone’s new favorite breakfast. Feels almost like sneaking dessert first thing in the morning. These days, my family will only eat French toast out if it can match this one I make – usually, they’re disappointed!

One brunch, even my mother-in-law—she never asks how to make things—asked for this. Now my son’s friends almost always show up hungry whenever I mention I'm making "the French toast." I think there’s just something about the crispy edges, creamy inside, and those sweet strawberries that makes everyone put down their phones and just enjoy their breakfast.

Vibrant Ingredients

• Brioche bread: Go for the rich, buttery kind—it’s just perfect for soaking up flavor. If you’ve got challah, that’ll work too. Regular white bread or Texas toast? They'll never be as good.
• Cream cheese: Full-fat (room temp!) gets you the dreamiest texture. I go with Philadelphia but any brand will do. Lighter versions aren’t as silky but still work.
• Fresh strawberries: They’re what make each bite bright and juicy. Use ripe ones when you can. If it’s winter, well-drained thawed frozen berries are okay, but fresh is best for great texture.
• Vanilla extract: A splash of real vanilla in the eggs gives that tasty finishing touch. Ran out once; breakfast just wasn’t the same.
• Cinnamon: I like tossing in just a bit with the eggs. Adds a subtle warmth. Sometimes I even sneak in a dash of nutmeg for an extra layer.

Save

Easy Steps

Getting smooth filling

Make sure your cream cheese is soft—that’s the trick for a lump-free mix. I leave it out for half an hour. Beat it up with powdered sugar first, then gently mix in diced strawberries. I once rushed it with hard cream cheese and, well, the lumps still tasted good but looked a little sad.

Thick slices work best

You want your brioche sliced thick, about an inch. Thinner slices just fall apart, thick ones might stay raw inside. I like grabbing unsliced loaves at the store so I can cut exactly what I want. If you only have pre-sliced, be gentle when dunking them.

Even filling means better bites

Use diced berries instead of slices so every bite gets a little strawberry. Spread filling close to the edge but not all the way—gives it space to ooze that creamy center without making a mess in the pan.

Dipping made easy

Give the stuffed bread a quick dip, about five seconds each side, to soak up just enough egg. Too long and it gets mushy, too quick and it won’t brown nicely. Aim for a light, even coating.

Cook at the right temp

Keep it at medium heat for a pretty, golden crust that’s not burnt. Not too low or it turns soggy. I use either a nonstick pan or well-oiled cast iron and melt a bit of butter for each batch for perfect browning and zero sticking.

Serve fast

They taste best right off the skillet, hot and crisp. If you’re feeding a crowd, toss finished ones in a 200°F oven so everyone gets them warm. I like to shower on some powdered sugar at the last second and pour maple syrup into tiny pitchers for everyone.

When I first tried this, I filled them way too much and it all oozed out while cooking! It tasted good but cleaning up was a pain. Now I chop strawberries smaller and chill the stuffed bread for a bit—it keeps the filling together when it hits the pan.

Magical Morning

These French toast sandwiches look fancy, so I like to serve them with a pile of extra berries and a little pitcher of warm syrup on regular days. For big brunches, I go nuts with whipped cream and berry compote, maybe some chocolate drizzle if it’s a celebration. Crisp bacon or sausage on the side? That combo always disappears. And don’t forget a glass of something bubbly—it turns an ordinary morning into a party fast!

Tasty Twists

This stuffed French toast is so flexible for flavor spins. Use diced mango or pineapple with a hint of coconut extract for sunny, tropical vibes. Want something cozy for fall? Add cinnamon apples cooked with brown sugar. My daughter gets happy when I mix in mini chocolate chips. For a grown-ups-only breakfast, try a splash of liqueur and some orange zest in the filling.

Lasting Freshness

Honestly, these are unbeatable when they’re freshly cooked. But if you need to plan ahead, you can build the cream cheese and bread sandwiches, chill them up to 4 hours, then dip and cook when you’re ready. Leftovers reheat in the oven at 350°F for around 10 minutes, but expect them a little less crisp. Freezing them doesn’t work out—the strawberries turn mushy when thawed.

Save

This dish started as a way to clear out leftovers, but now it’s our family’s favorite way to start a weekend. The mix of warm bread, cool creamy filling, and juicy berries feels like you’re treating yourself—even when it’s just regular Saturday. And while it looks like a showstopper, it’s honestly simple to make—no fancy tools or flipping skills needed! There's always a happy reaction when I set these powdered, golden stacks on the table, and that’s why I keep making them again and again.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can other breads work for this?

Absolutely! Brioche is fantastic because it's rich and sturdy, but challah, French baguette, or thick-sliced Texas toast works too. Just go for slices that are about an inch thick to hold the good stuff.

→ Is frozen fruit an option?

Fresh berries are the way to go, but thawed frozen strawberries can work. Just make sure to get rid of extra liquid once thawed, or your bread might turn soggy.

→ How do I keep the toast warm while finishing up the rest?

Pop finished slices onto a baking tray and keep them in a 200°F oven. They'll stay warm and won't overcook.

→ Can this be prepped the night before?

You can whip up the creamy filling and egg dip ahead of time and chill them in the fridge. But assemble and cook it fresh in the morning for the best bite and texture.

→ What goes well with this dish?

Besides syrup or extra strawberries, add crispy bacon, sausage, a dab of whipped cream, or even some chopped nuts for texture.