Save
Plump garlic-infused shrimp in a creamy buttery sauce might sound like something from a fancy seafood spot, but honestly, I toss this together on hectic evenings way faster than any delivery guy can make it. This dish has pulled me out of dinner emergencies more times than I'm willing to admit—especially when friends just pop over or I need to impress but don't wanna sweat it. Shrimp soaks up all the garlicky goodness, making it taste like you spent your whole day prepping. Tom, my neighbor, once joked I must be hiding takeout bags from that pricey bistro, but nope! It's just me with a skillet and a bunch of stuff from my pantry knocking this out on the fly.
Why You'll Want This Fast
- You'll look like you totally know what you're doing, even if you don't
- Pairs perfectly with bread for dipping, over pasta, or with some steamy rice
- You likely already have everything in the kitchen
- Ready and on the table in just 15 minutes, for real
- Looks fancy but no effort—good for last-minute hosting or eating solo on a lazy night
The first time I put this together was right after a huge blackout a few years ago. Power came back and I had a tiny window to cook before my freezer stuff went bad. My husband—usually super picky about seafood—basically cleaned his plate. Now he wants this every birthday, which I'm fine with, since that means less time cooking, more time chilling with everyone.
Super-Fresh Tastes Best
- If you want your shrimp to brown, dry them really well before cooking—wet shrimp will just steam
- Peeled and deveined shrimp only—don’t bother with shells for this, it needs to be quick
- The flavor is all about real garlic, not the jarred stuff (seriously, skip it)
- Go for a hunk of real Parmesan—not the stuff in the green can that smells weird
I learned the importance of drying shrimp when my in-laws smiled politely through what tasted like bands of rubbery cream. Total facepalm moment. Now, I always pat them dry with paper towels and leave them sitting while I get my garlic and other bits chopped. Dave at the seafood shop swears wild shrimp is next-level, but honestly, decent farmed shrimp work fine when I’m watching the grocery bill.
Save
Easy Step-by-Step
- Start With The Sauce
- Add chicken broth (or white wine) to the pan you just cooked the shrimp in, scrape up everything stuck at the bottom, and let it bubble for about a minute. Stream in heavy cream while stirring. Add some lemon juice and Italian herbs, sprinkling in Parmesan little by little instead of dumping it all (trust me, you'll avoid cheese blobs). Let it gently simmer until thick but still runny enough to coat a spoon. Adjust seasoning, if needed.
- Sauté The Garlic
- Drop butter into the hot pan, let it melt, then throw in minced garlic with some red pepper flakes if you're feeling spicy. Keep stirring so it softens but doesn't brown (burnt garlic stinks up the whole kitchen, don’t let that happen).
- Sear The Shrimp
- Get olive oil shimmering in a big skillet. Lay out the shrimp in a single layer, seasoned with salt and pepper, and don't cram them—work in batches if you have to. Let them sit still for a minute so they get some color, then flip. Pull them out when they're shaped like a C, not an O (O means overcooked, and you don't want that). Slide them onto a plate for now.
- Finish It Off
- Flip the shrimp back into the creamy sauce with all the tasty juices from the plate. Fold gently to coat and warm them through, about a minute. After tasting and adjusting salt and pepper, toss on some chopped parsley for a pop of color. It makes everything look way better than just beige food.
Grandma Rita taught me most of my kitchen tricks. She claimed garlic is its own food group and could always tell by the smell if I'd rushed it. She’d smash cloves and fill the room with stories of old apartments where you knew what was for dinner just by the hallway aroma. Her voice still pops in my head every time I think of skipping or hurrying the garlic, so I never do.
Tasty Pairings
Swirl this over skinny angel hair for a lightning-quick meal, or go with thick slices of sourdough for mopping every drop. Sometimes I embarrass the kids by swiping my finger around the plate for leftovers. Need something lighter? Zucchini noodles or cauliflower rice do the job, though my husband complains "real carbs" make it perfect.
Mix Things Up
Fancy it up with scallops or swap for chicken if seafood’s not the vibe. For some color, throw in halved cherry tomatoes at the end, or wilt a big handful of spinach right into the sauce. Want something different? Mix in crumbled feta and chopped olives, swapping out half the Parmesan for a Greek spin.
Leftover Tips
Leftovers keep for two days in the fridge, but honestly, it’s magic fresh. Sauce might separate when chilled, but heat it slowly on the stove while stirring and splash in a bit of cream to smooth it out. Microwaving shrimp is a hard pass—rubber band city. Got just leftover sauce? Turn it into a super quick chowder with some broth and extra fish tossed in.
Save
Kitchen Tricks
If the sauce splits or gets funky, a bit more cream over gentle heat and some whisking should bring it back
Use finely grated Parmesan for the smoothest sauce—big shreds won’t melt well
Just before serving, squeeze a wedge of lemon over it to freshen it up
This one’s my go-to for everything from fancy date nights to eating alone when I just want something comforting. No need for complicated steps—if you’ve got good ingredients, that’s all you need. If you dry the shrimp well and treat the garlic right, you’ll have people begging for seconds (and your secret). Promise me you won’t rush those parts!
Recipe FAQs
- → Is it okay to use frozen shrimp?
- Sure! Just let them thaw fully and pat dry so the sauce doesn’t end up watery.
- → What sides go best with this?
- Rice, pasta, mashed potatoes, or even crusty bread to soak up all the sauce work great!
- → Can this be made without dairy?
- Swap in coconut cream for heavy cream and try nutritional yeast instead of Parmesan, keeping in mind the taste will change.
- → How spicy is this dish?
- The red pepper flakes give it a mild heat, but you can leave them out or add more depending on what you like.
- → Can I prep this dish in advance?
- It’s tastiest right after being made, but leftovers can be reheated on low with a splash of cream to revive the sauce.
- → Which wine pairs nicely with it?
- A light Sauvignon Blanc or Pinot Grigio balances the creamy sauce wonderfully.