Save
On nights when I want something that’s pure comfort but a little fancier than the usual grilled cheese, these cheesy patty melts with their crave-worthy sauce totally hit the spot. You get juicy beef with just enough seasoning, a melty duo of cheeses, and that next-level bacon-packed sauce—all tucked inside crispy, buttery rye bread. It’s like the ultimate burger smashed together with grilled cheese and somehow, it’s even better. Honestly, these came together because I really couldn’t decide between a burger or a grilled cheese, so I just went for both at once—and wow, it’s now my go-to craving fix.
My teenager’s super picky most days, but after his first bite, he said, "This is hands-down the best sandwich I’ve eaten." Now he skips his usual birthday dinner out—and just asks for a stack of these at home. That’s about as good as a parent can hope for.
Irresistible Patty Melts
- Bread with attitude: Rye’s slight zing really plays up all the bold tastes
- Patties packed with flavor: Beef gets shaped and seasoned just to fit, so every bite’s tasty
- Cheese layered like a pro: Tangy cheddar joins super-smooth provolone for the best melt
- Sauce with bacon: Not your regular spread—bacon’s crunch and smoke take it over the top
- Sweet-tangy hit: Relish and sugar blended in the sauce for a blast of flavor balance
Save
Cooking Steps Made Simple
- Sizzling on the griddle:
- Once built, pop them back in the skillet. Grill one side until golden and gooey, then carefully flip and crisp up the other. The cheese should be stretch-level melted.
- Stacking it up:
- Wipe out your pan and lower the heat. Butter the outside of each rye slice. Lay three slices buttered-side down, then go: provolone, beef patty, cheddar, then slather the sauce on your top piece before closing them up.
- Sauce time:
- In a small bowl, blend mayo with crumbled bacon, ketchup, sweet relish, and a pinch of sugar. The bacon makes it smoky, and the relish wakes up your taste buds.
- Patty prep:
- Split your beef into three chunks and press each one so it covers your bread perfectly. Hit both sides with salt, pepper, onion powder, and garlic powder, then fry on medium-high for a good 4-5 minutes a side until cooked through. Take them out and set aside.
If you blast the heat, the bread burns up way before the cheese melts. Take your time, stick with medium, and you’ll always get that perfect crispy crust with oozing cheese.
Awesome Sides to Add
Honestly, one of these is enough to fill you up, but if you want to go all out, pile on crunchy onion rings or fries. A cold pickle spear adds a sharp bite that cuts through all the richness. Grab a frosty beer or some classic cola—either one just works with these flavors.
Try Some Fun Twists
Switch up the bread—sourdough and pumpernickel both totally work. Throw some sautéed onions on the patties if that’s your style, or swap in Swiss or American for different cheese vibes. Playing with the sauce is fun too: use another type of relish or squirt in some hot sauce for a kick.
Keeping Leftovers Tasty
These are absolute best straight out of the pan, but if you have extras, warm them up in a skillet on medium so you get that crispy hit back. The microwave’s fast, but the bread goes soggy—skillet’s worth the extra few minutes.
Save
Honestly, these cheesy patty melts with that dreamy sauce are now the meal I pull out when I want to make dinner feel special. All those favorite comfort flavors turned up a notch—it’s nostalgic, but also new every time. Everyone around the table just digs in and quiets down, busy loving every bite.
Recipe FAQs
- → Why does the sauce taste so unique?
- It's a blend of mayo, ketchup, relish, bacon crumbles, and sugar. Sweet and tangy, it pairs beautifully with the beef and cheese.
- → What’s a good bread alternative?
- While rye is classic, sourdough or thick white slices hold up well too. Go for something sturdy that absorbs juices without falling apart.
- → How can I stop the cheese from seeping out?
- Don’t overstuff your sandwich, and cook over medium heat so the cheese melts evenly. Lightly press down with a spatula as you cook.
- → Can a gluten-free version be made?
- Totally! Use gluten-free bread with some weight to it and double-check that your sauces are gluten-free.
- → Any tricks for flipping these cleanly?
- Grab a wide spatula, flip in one swift motion, and don't overthink it. Another option? Lay a plate on top, flip onto it, then slide back onto the pan.