Save
Get ready for cloud-like, ultra-cheesy potatoes that will steal the show at any meal. I set out to make a version that tasted like my grandma’s legendary creation—the one everyone fought over at reunions—and, with some tinkering, I totally nailed that addictive balance between dreamy-soft middles and a shatteringly crisp top. Thin potato slices soak up garlicky cream and a double hit of cheese, turning humble spuds into something people can’t stop talking about. The secret? Extra attention to the last broil for that crunchy finish and velvety center.
Irresistible Reasons You'll Want to Make This
- Whips up enough to fill a big group (but you can shrink it down for smaller nights)
- Makes your weeknight chicken (or fancy steak) instantly special
- Turns just a handful of basics into over-the-top, cheesy goodness
- Nails that combo of crispy topping and creamy potatoes under it
- Packed with so much flavor, it tastes like something from your favorite bistro
The first time I shared this at a party, Beth (who seriously swore off carbs) snuck back for seconds, then thirds—then begged me for all the details. Her husband joked that their meal plans were totally wrecked. Some things are just worth breaking the rules for. Now, whenever I get invited to events, people don’t even ask what I’m bringing—they know it’s going to be this.
Ingredients
- Stick with russet potatoes for ideal, creamy texture—they lend a thickness that’s just right
- Peel them for that extra-silky feel
- Paper-thin slices are key—grab a mandolin unless you love a workout
- Uniform slices keep everything cooking evenly so you don’t get any raw bits
- Pick potatoes that are fresh—no green patches or sprouts for best taste
Mom used to say soaking potato slices gets rid of too much starch, but honestly, here, you want that extra starch for a nice, luscious sauce. The spuds let it out as they bake, mingling with cream into a sauce you’ll want to eat straight off the spoon.
Save
Simple Step-by-Step
- Preparation Perfection
- Start by really heating up your oven—no short cuts there. Rub your baking dish all over with butter so nothing sticks, hitting the corners, too. Eyes and dark spots on potatoes? Toss them. Go for the thinnest slices you can make, using that mandolin set super-low for best results. Uniform cuts mean all the potatoes turn out tender and creamy and soak up everything you add.
- Cream Magic
- Mix heavy cream, grated Parmesan, white cheddar, plus that finely chopped garlic in a big bowl. The finer you chop the garlic, the better—no one wants a giant garlic surprise bite. Drop your potatoes into this goodness, and use your hands to get every slice dressed and separated. Take your time so every piece gets a flavor boost.
- Arranging Artfully
- Take handfuls of cream-coated potato slices and stack them up vertically—don’t lay them flat—so the sauce slips between all the layers. Place them upright and snug but with just enough space so the cream can move around. When you’ve filled the dish, pour any extra cream over top so it trickles through every layer.
- Oven Game Plan
- Cover tightly with foil first so you trap steam and soften all the potato layers without toasting the top too early. Once potatoes are nice and soft (but not mushy), remove the foil. Then scatter more Parmesan on for that killer golden topping. The short broil at the end matters—a lot. That’s when you get the deep brown, crispy top that everyone fights over. Don’t skip it!
The cheese choice can totally make or break this dish. I’ve played with lots of combos, but sharp white cheddar plus Parmesan is the dream team—melty and flavorful! My aunt once grabbed a bag of pre-grated cheese and couldn’t figure out why her sauce looked curdled and oily. Turns out, pre-shredded cheese often has stuff that keeps it from melting right. Always use a box grater with real chunks for a gorgeously creamy sauce.
Serving Inspiration
This pairs like magic with basic roast chicken or beef for a Sunday night treat. On the holidays, it holds its own right on the table with glazed ham or prime rib. Because it’s so creamy, you’ll want to stick to simply cooked meats and skip the heavy sauces. Toss a tart, zippy salad (think vinaigrette!) on the side to cut through all that rich, cheesy goodness.
Fun Ways to Mix It Up
For sweet flavor, slide in layers of caramelized onions. Swap in Gruyère if you want a French twist. Want a herby kick? Stir in fresh rosemary or thyme with your cream. Making it into a meal? Slide thin ham slices between potatoes for a heartier dish. Try a dash of nutmeg, too—it adds a cozy note that’s so good with all that cheese.
Keep it Fresh
Leftovers keep best tightly covered in your fridge up to three days—they’re even tastier after soaking up cream overnight. For reheating, pop the dish into a 325°F oven with foil covering the top for about 20 minutes so everything heats evenly. Microwave if you must, but your potatoes might get a bit grainy and the sauce could split. Freezing? Do it before baking the last time, then thaw fully and bake fresh for best results.
Save
Chef's Best Advice
Let cream come up to room temp if you want to keep it from splitting in the oven
Add a good bit of salt—taste your cream and cheese blend first so it’s never bland
Try a wide, shallow dish so there’s plenty of crunchy topping to go around
Stacking potatoes upright gives you way more texture and looks cool, too
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve played with this dish, fussing with details over years of holidays until getting it just right. Stood the slices up tall after seeing a mind-blowing presentation at a Montreal bistro and never went back. The best part is watching someone bite in for the first time—there’s always a look of surprise when they realize these are a huge upgrade from plain potatoes. Even those who claim they’re not fans change their minds. It’s so loved that my family always texts long before a get-together, making sure I’m not showing up empty-handed on “the potatoes.”
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I prep the dish the day before?
- Definitely! Assemble everything, cover, and store in the fridge overnight. When baking, add about 10-15 minutes for the cold ingredients to warm through.
- → How are scalloped potatoes different from these?
- Scalloped potatoes traditionally skip cheese, but this dish uses plenty of it! Plus, au gratin recipes aim for that crispy, browned top layer.
- → Do I have to use a mandolin slicer?
- Not necessarily, but it makes thin, even slices much easier. If using a knife, go slow to ensure consistent cuts so they cook evenly.
- → Can I swap in other cheeses?
- Of course! Gruyère is a classic, but options like gouda, fontina, or sharp yellow cheddar would work beautifully. Try mixing different types for fun.
- → Why aren’t my potatoes soft enough?
- This might happen if the slices are too thick or the first bake wasn’t well-covered. Covered baking traps steam, which is key to softening the potatoes.
- → What other flavors could I add?
- Feel free to toss in fresh thyme or rosemary, add a hint of nutmeg, or layer in caramelized onions for extra depth.